Is Hard or Soft Luggage Better?

As an avid globetrotter, I have learned that luggage comes in two main forms – hardside and softside. Both have their unique benefits and drawbacks that cater to different types of travelers and trips. With years of experience hauling suitcases of all shapes and sizes across dozens of countries, I’ve become well-versed in the pros and cons of each type.

In this blog post, I’ll share my insights to help you determine if sturdy hardside or flexible softside luggage is the right fit for your needs. We’ll dive into the key differences, so you can make an informed decision when purchasing your next travel bag. By understanding the strengths and weaknesses of these two main options, you can pack smarter for your next big trip!

Hardside Luggage

Hardside luggage is typically made of materials like polycarbonate, ABS plastic, or aluminum. The rigid shell makes it extremely durable and protective of your belongings.

Pros of Hardside Luggage

• More durable – The tough, inflexible exterior prevents dents, tears, and damage. It holds up better to the rough handling of crowded airports and careless baggage handlers.
• Very secure – The locking mechanisms and lack of flexibility make it difficult for thieves to break in. Your items stay protected.
• Easy to clean – Spills and dirt wipe off the smooth exterior easily.
• Distinctive – The sleek, uniform look makes your suitcase easy to spot on the carousel.
• Stands up on its own – No need to prop it against something to keep it upright.

Cons of Hardside Luggage

• Heavy – The materials add extra weight before you even start packing.
• Can crack or shatter – While durable, the inflexible shell is also brittle and may crack on impact.
• Difficult to stuff to capacity – The fixed shape limits how much you can fit inside. Packing cubes or compression bags help.
• Expensive – Quality hardside luggage usually comes with a higher price tag.
• Shows scratches – Scuffs and scratches on the exterior are easily visible.

[amazon box=”B00BTK17JI”]

Softside Luggage

Soft luggage is made from fabrics like nylon, polyester, and canvas. It gets its structure from lightweight frames or simple cardboard reinforcements.

Pros of Softside Luggage

• Lightweight – The fabric and flexible frame minimize the empty weight.
• Expands easily – You can really stuff these bags full and the sides will still zip.
• Packs flat for storage – Collapsing the frame lets it lie flat in your closet when not in use.
• Easier to carry – Without a bulky hard shell, it’s less strain on your arms and shoulders.
• Variety of styles – Come in endless colors and patterns to suit your tastes.

Cons of Softside Luggage

• Less durable – Fabrics can rip, fray, and show wear and tear over time.
• Less secure – Slash-able fabric and accessible zippers make theft a concern. Use TSA locks.
• Can tip over – Without a solid base, packed bags become top-heavy and prone to falling.
• Weather vulnerability – Fabrics can soak through in the rain and retain odors or stains.
• Plain styles cost less – Unique prints and features bump up the price tag.

[amazon box=”B06XVSR3JZ”]

The Verdict

For frequent travelers who want maximum protection for their belongings, hardside luggage is the way to go. If light weight and flexibility are your main concerns, softside is likely the better choice.

There are high-quality options available in both categories—you don’t have to sacrifice durability for softness or vice versa. Pay attention to the materials and components when shopping around. Advanced fabrics and sturdy yet lightweight frames provide the best of both worlds.

The optimal solution may also be packing both hard and soft luggage. Use a tough hardside case for checked baggage where scrapes and impacts are likely. Bring a compact softside carry-on bag for easy access to belongings during the flight. Mix, match and find what combination satisfies your style, budget, and travel needs.

No matter your choice, the right luggage should share your sense of adventure while keeping your belongings safe. Let me know if you have any other luggage questions! I’m always happy to discuss travel gear.